9 Wintersleep – The Great Detachment
Wintersleep’s sixth studio album marked a return to form for the group. Compared to the band’s previous two efforts these tracks sound absolutely expansive. It was recorded primarily live-off-the-floor at their old stomping grounds of the Sonic Temple in Halifax (the same location they recorded their first 3 albums). |
8 Hannah Georgas – For Evelyn
For Evelyn is Georgas’ most confident record yet. Though she opens it by admitting, “I wake up in the middle of the night thinking, ‘Oh my God, who the hell am I?'” an assertiveness quickly quells these late night anxieties as she becomes determined to take hold of her life. This self-assurance shines through again when her response to the end of a relationship is acceptance, singing, “When you left me, I was ready for you to leave” (“Walls”) and again as she courageously says goodbye to a city that no longer feels like home (“City”). |
7 White Lung – Paradise
White Lung pride themselves on overwhelming listeners, pushing their skills to the limit, and though it sometimes seems like they may box themselves into a corner, with each release the Vancouver- and Los Angeles-based quartet manage to push the walls further outward, making subtle tweaks to their formula that reveal deeper depths to their aural attack. |
6 A Tribe Called Red – We Are the Halluci Nation
We Are the Halluci Nation is an extremely well executed concept album that sticks unwaveringly to its vision. The late singer/American Indian activist John Trudell’s recitation introduces the concept right from the jump: we can all be part of the Halluci Nation if we wake up and reject current ways of living in iniquity and learn to truly love and understand one another. |
5 Leonard Cohen – You Want It Darker
You Want It Darker finds the musician reflecting upon what once was and what can no longer be. It’s classic Cohen, making mention of death, romance and religion, the latter being the strongest theme here, as he shows curiosity surrounding death, some regret regarding romance and a belief in God but a disappointment with him and fellow believers, too. But most evident of all is an acceptance of all three. |
4 John K. Samson – Winter Wheat
Winter Wheat is fairly comparable to Samson’s debut Provincial, though broader in scope and subject matter. His lyrics are varied, vivid and heavily inspired — by novels, documentaries, history books and more — as he tests the boundaries of his literary creativity, exploring a vast range of narratives, perspectives and topics. His substantial Neil Young influence (particularly 1974’s On the Beach) is quite apparent, perhaps nowhere more than on “Vampire Alberta Blues.” The song, with a title taken right from one of Don Grungio’s own, has a distinctly Youngian feel to it while extending an anti-oil industry message, the kind that Young has been spreading for decades. |
3 Andy Shauf – The Party
Most of these songs are set at a house party, so though Shauf insists this isn’t a concept record, there’s at least a sense that they exist in the same world; you’ll discover, for example, reoccurring characters, a technique Shauf has mastered since his last full-length release, The Bearer of Bad News. Like Randy Newman and Paul Simon before him, Shauf has a mind for creating character narratives that tell a tale in mere minutes’ time. These are characters you’ll quickly find yourself caring for, that you’ll wonder about once the song’s up, that you’ll hope will find the happiness they all seem starved for. |
2 Tanya Tagaq – Retribution
On her fourth album, Retribution Tagaq achieves an experience as potent as, and analogous to, her live show: Retribution is immersive, cathartic, potentially even transformative. And while on Animism some of Tagaq’s political beliefs were implied (and in the case of “Fracking,” frightfully clear), this time around she’s taken things farther and deeper, made her outspoken messages more outspoken, more crystal clear. |
1 Basia Bulat – Good Advice
Like her Polaris-shortlisted and Juno-nominated 2013 album Tall, Tall Shadow, Good Advice deals frankly and intimately with loss. Musically, it also continues Bulat’s exploration of electronic sounds over folk storytelling. This time, keyboards of various eras and moods dominate, from the opening notes of “La, La, Lie” to the plucky ballad “Time,” which features vintage Hammond Novachord (recorded at the National Music Centre in Calgary, which houses the rare instrument); Mellotron haunts the cinematic closer “Someday Soon.” Producer Jim James (of My Morning Jacket) brings the same balance to the soundscapes Bulat maintains with her lyrics, positioning the space-age synths and backup harmonies in ways that invoke both gospel and girl group traditions without overshadowing the album’s strongest suit: Bulat’s vibrant vocals. |
Hello
Sorry about the lack of new content over the last ten days or so, I will try to improve over the forthcoming year.
Geez, it’s not as though there’s a lot of action otherwise…
Happy New Year!
It shouldn’t all be up to you Garf.
How did Black Mountain not make it on our list? What’s wrong with you people? hehe
Good morning everyone! Happy to be back… how are you feeling Garf?
Good morning!
Good choices.
Happy 2017!
You know what? I didn’t even know Cohen released an album last year. Listening to it now before they revoke my citizenship.
loozr, he’s your man!
I wasn’t aware either Loozrboy.
I received The Secret Path for Xmas from my sweetie. It is a really good album as well.
Some of my other favourite albums of 2016:
Black Mountain – IV
Royal Canoe – Something Got Lost Between Here and The Orbit
Suuns – Hold/Still
Holy Fuck – Congrats
Plants and Animals – Waltzed in From The Rumbling
PUP – The Dream is Over
Sarah Neufeld – The Ridge
Hannah Epperson – Upsweep
and so many more! It was such a great year of music for me.
My playlist on Friday had a list of 100 songs from artists that released new music in 2016. It was a pretty great list I must say.
http://open.spotify.com/user/darbarspecial/playlist/6ippgZoup3STnUfRnFw6JF
I agree,t there was a lot of great music in 2016! Glad we were here to share in it:)
It has been tough for me to partake of live music due to lack of local bookings so I have been especially glad to be a part of Ourbasement to keep me inspired and in the loop.
I am follow Loozerboys lead and listening to LC.
I have heard cuts from all of the other albums but rarely the full albums … and very little of White Lung and TT; that is going to be my project today! Full album Friday … holiday confusion over what day of the week it is ensues;)
http://exclaim.ca/film/article/heres_your_first_look_at_terrence_malicks_film_about_the_austin_music_scene?utm_source=facebookpage&utm_medium=referral&utm_campaign=fbpwall
I really am not a fan of Ryan Gosling but I may be sucked in by the story line … what do you think?
Hello from wonderfully rainy northern California.
I have a question on this list. It indicates the Top 9 albums, but what is the measurement? And where is the information complied from? Not trying to be snarky about this, but how was this Top 9 determined?
And happy new year to all. Four days until Peggy and I run down to the Bay Area to first see Grant in a reading from his new book on his life with the Smugglers, and then that evening, to see the Smugglers perform for the first time in 13 or 14 years.
I can’t wait for you to do a write up for us (mostly) Canadians who won’t be going to the US to see The Smugglers!
Do you think Grant will grant you an interview!
Morgana – Grant is coming to stay with us a couple of days. And I’ll do a write up. I assume I send it to Garry.
Garf did a survey asking people for their top 10 albums awhile back. I assume the list was mostly made from that.
I had a feeling/was hoping for a response like that @mcfflyer. here’s to you and peggy enjoying the show and hosting!
There is a “contribute” top right of this page and yes, it goes to Garry at this point.
Ourbasementblog@gmail.com
Is the email
Yo @mcfflyer… be sure to get some photos of Grant and you and Grant, etc. Great for the blog post. Is this for him being in Sac for the Smugglers show?
I’m back after a break. I’ll get photos. I take photos at every show I go to, although they are getting fewer and fewer, but this is one I will not miss. Back in the “old” R3 days, I’d try to use one photo from the show as my profile photo the next day.
If Garry did a survey of everyone’s Top 10 and came up with this, then great! There’s something behind it, although it really is “our”basement’s top albums, although I am curious as to how many did submit lists to Garry. And no, I don’t have any, nor have I heard any of them. My last new Canadian album was given to me by Peggy a year ago for Christmas, Coeur de Pirate’s latest record, Roses. And this is someone who I only knew about because Radio3 played her. It’s kind of odd, as not all of the songs are in French. Some are in English!
I was always wondering just how Radio3 ever came up with the R3-30 listing, and what made one song higher than another on it. To me it made more sense to just call it “30 of the current top R3 hits” or something like that, but not rank them, since it appears that ranking was pretty arbitrary, unlike the old American Top 40 days (with Casey Kasem!) where the Top 40 was the ranking done by Billboard Magazine based on sales and radio airplay.
Justin, I had a welcome mat out for Grant for years, since my first visit to R3 in 2009. But this is the first time he’s even in the area, although he seems to love going down to Palm Springs. And yes, he’s coming to Sacramento because he is somewhat nearby, and there might never be another chance. He’ll be here for a couple of nights, and I need to figure out just what to do to entertain him. Since he isn’t a wine drinker, my normal visitor tour, going up to our foothill wine country is probably not in the cards, but 90 miles north of here is the third largest micro brewer in the states, Sierra Nevada Brewery, in Chico. We could go up there and take a tour – depends on what he wants to do.
How’s Duke doing?
@mcfflyer… Duke is doing great. He’s been curled up in front of the fireplace by the Christmas tree today, tough life.
@mcfflyer…. For Grant… yes, beer is the way to go. Get photos of you, him, Peggy, and Jill, out, etc too.
Justin, if Jill is coming down, that’s news to me. We’d be thrilled to have the entire family, but I suspect it’ll only be Grant.
@Lee – If you saw my 100 list post, you read how I struggled with what to call it. It was kind of a top 100 but not really and I certainly wasn’t going to put in the time to figure out how to rank them. I only had one song per artist on it so ended up with a 100 artists of 2016 list.
@mcfflyer… ah RE Jill… she is super cool. Garf, Reg, Zammachus, and myself got to meet her in London, ON last June.
Justin, yes, I know and a lovely hostess. On my/our last visit to Vancouver to attend AlexofAnders wedding, we were invited out to their house, and I believe I was the first of the Radio3 community to actually hold baby Joshua who was about six months old at the time. Jill served little cookies and cakes, with coffee, and it’s as I would imagine would happen in Canada!
Weaves! That was another great album this year.
Weaves also did one of the T. Hip covers that was a standout.
The 9 albums were taken from reader responses. Any ties were broken by a few methods including how it had ranked on other end of year lists and it’s score on metacritic.
As for number of responses. We got less than 9, more than that I am not willing to say.
As for the R3:30, I believe that at first it was a combination of staff selection and thumbs up, then becoming click bait an online vote, before eventually returning to staff selections. This is just what I have priced together from conversations over time.
Well, it has been an interesting afternoon of listening;
I woke up with some classic Canadian crooning that made me think of my Mom
Winter Wheat seemed to blend into the back ground while I puttered on FB and chores so then I tried
Hannah whose stories of family and self questioning kept me going quite nicely. I have enjoyed singles but never the whole album in one go so that was enjoyable.
After walking the dog through the frozen tundra that is my town right now I put on Tanya. The album is quite the piece of art. Would I put it on to relax and enjoy some music? Nope. But the album has found a place of interest in me.
White Lung was my next stop but I just couldn’t do it. Three songs in I needed to change the pace to something more recognizable and comfortable for my ear.
Andy and Basia have effortlessly escorted me through baking and dinner making.
I guess I just need to finish the night off with some electronic powwow to complete things!
Why didn’t Wintersleep figure into the day … maybe just saving it for tomorrow;)
Thanks for the listening and pondering place.
Thanks for the explanation, Garry. You said you had less than 9 respondents. But why the secrecy over that? For heavens sake, we’re all friends here, and have been for years, and we certainly share a lot about ourselves and our lives. I’m not surprised you had a low number of respondents. I couldn’t respond, as I had no new albums or any that I’d listened to. Sadly, our pool here in the basement is quite tiny. I think I tallied a total of 19 different people chiming in all month. And unlike the old days of the R3 blog, I doubt if there are many lurkers. Alas, it’s just us. Really, we’re the survivors, and it seems like there are fewer and fewer of us.
Happy new year.
We have had a few stories of people that were around R3 that have shown up here and happy to find us. We are struggling right now but it could really be a great place if given the chance and more people that want to build us up and not tear us down.